All comparisons

Three-toed Box Turtle vs Western Painted Turtle

How does the Three-toed Box Turtle compare to the Western Painted Turtle? They are both members of the Emydidae family. Below we put their classification, habitat, diet, size, and conservation status side by side — and settle who would win in a fight.

Three-toed Box Turtle
Western Painted Turtle

Side-by-side comparison

Three-toed Box Turtle
Western Painted Turtle
Scientific name
Terrapene carolina triunguis
Chrysemys picta bellii
Classification
Reptile
Reptile
Family
Emydidae
Emydidae
Habitat
Moist woodlands and forest edges
Freshwater ponds, lakes, marshes, and slow-moving rivers with soft, muddy bottoms and abundant vegetation.
Diet
Omnivore
Omnivore
Conservation status
Vulnerable
Least Concern
Lifespan
30-50 years
20-40 years
Weight
300-500 grams
300-600 grams

Three-toed Box Turtle vs Western Painted Turtle: who would win?

Three-toed Box Turtle

Three-toed Box Turtle

300-500 grams

VS
Western Painted Turtle

Western Painted Turtle

300-600 grams

Too close to call speculative confidence

Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle are closely matched on both size (300-500 grams vs 300-600 grams) and diet, so the outcome would come down to circumstance. In the wild these two rarely (if ever) meet — this is a what-if based on the size and diet we have on record, not a prediction.

Similarities

  • Both are reptiles.
  • Both belong to the Emydidae family.
  • Both have a omnivore diet.

Differences

  • Habitat: Moist woodlands and forest edges vs Freshwater ponds, lakes, marshes, and slow-moving rivers with soft, muddy bottoms and abundant vegetation..
  • Conservation: Vulnerable vs Least Concern.
  • Weight: 300-500 grams vs 300-600 grams.

Three-toed Box Turtle vs Western Painted Turtle: FAQ

Who would win in a fight, a Three-toed Box Turtle or a Western Painted Turtle?

Too close to call. Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle are closely matched on both size (300-500 grams vs 300-600 grams) and diet, so the outcome would come down to circumstance. In the wild these two rarely (if ever) meet — this is a what-if based on the size and diet we have on record, not a prediction.

What is the difference between a Three-toed Box Turtle and a Western Painted Turtle?

Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle differ in several ways — habitat: moist woodlands and forest edges vs freshwater ponds, lakes, marshes, and slow-moving rivers with soft, muddy bottoms and abundant vegetation.. conservation: vulnerable vs least concern. weight: 300-500 grams vs 300-600 grams.

Do Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle live in the same habitat?

No — Three-toed Box Turtle lives in moist woodlands and forest edges, while Western Painted Turtle is found in freshwater ponds, lakes, marshes, and slow-moving rivers with soft, muddy bottoms and abundant vegetation..

What do Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle eat?

Both Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle have a omnivore diet.

Which is more endangered, the Three-toed Box Turtle or the Western Painted Turtle?

Three-toed Box Turtle is listed as Vulnerable, while Western Painted Turtle is listed as Least Concern.

How big are Three-toed Box Turtle and Western Painted Turtle?

Three-toed Box Turtle weighs around 300-500 grams, while Western Painted Turtle weighs around 300-600 grams.

Three-toed Box Turtle

Full profile

Three-toed Box Turtle

Western Painted Turtle

Full profile

Western Painted Turtle